Do Numbing Creams Really Work for Piercings? A Medical Aesthetician Weighs In

So, you’re thinking about getting a piercing, but the thought of the needle makes you a bit squeamish? You’re not alone! Many people explore ways to minimize piercing discomfort, and numbing creams often top the list. But do they actually live up to the hype? Let’s dive into the science, separate fact from fiction, and explore the pros and cons of using numbing creams for piercings.

Understanding Numbing Creams: How Do They Work?

Numbing creams, also known as topical anesthetics, work by temporarily disrupting pain signals. They typically contain lidocaine or prilocaine, active ingredients that block sodium channels in your nerve endings. Think of these channels as tiny doorways; the anesthetic essentially closes these doors, preventing pain signals from reaching your brain. Dr. Penzi, a leading dermatologist, explains, “numbing creams are topical anesthetics that act by reversible inhibition of sodium ion influx, which blocks nerve conduction.” (Source: Byrdie) This creates a localized numbing effect, reducing the sensation of pain in the area where the cream is applied.

Numbing Creams and Piercings: Does Location Matter?

While numbing creams can lessen piercing pain, their effectiveness varies depending on several factors, including the location of the piercing. For example, earlobe piercings, where the tissue is relatively thin, may benefit more from numbing creams compared to cartilage piercings, where the thicker tissue can hinder the cream’s penetration. Some experts believe that the cream’s efficacy may also be influenced by individual skin thickness and sensitivity. Research suggests that individuals with thicker skin might require a higher concentration of anesthetic or a longer application time for optimal numbing.

Safety First: Potential Side Effects and Precautions

For most people, numbing creams are safe when used as directed. However, like any topical product, they can cause side effects such as redness, itching, or minor swelling. In rare cases, allergic reactions can occur. Therefore, performing a patch test before applying the cream to the piercing site is always recommended. This involves applying a small amount of cream to a less sensitive area, like your inner forearm, and observing for any adverse reactions over 24-48 hours.

Using Numbing Creams Effectively: A Step-by-Step Guide

  1. Cleanse: Thoroughly clean the piercing site with an antiseptic solution.
  2. Apply: Apply a generous layer of numbing cream, ensuring complete coverage of the area to be pierced. Consult the product instructions for the recommended thickness and application area.
  3. Cover: Use an occlusive dressing, such as plastic wrap (often provided by your piercer), to enhance absorption and prevent the cream from drying out. Again, refer to the product instructions for the recommended duration.
  4. Time it Right: Apply the cream the appropriate amount of time before your piercing appointment, as specified in the product instructions. This allows sufficient time for the numbing effect to take hold.

The Piercer’s Perspective: Why Some Professionals Say “No”

Many professional piercers advise against using numbing creams for several reasons:

  • Tissue Distortion: Numbing creams can alter the texture and tension of the skin, making it difficult for the piercer to accurately place the piercing. This can increase the risk of misplaced piercings or migration. As expert piercer Lynn Loheide notes, “numbing creams […] change the texture of the skin, making it very difficult for the piercer to get perfect placement. This [can] result in a piercing rejection, migration or an uneven, crooked piercing”
  • Unreliable Effectiveness: The depth and consistency of numbness achieved with topical creams can be unpredictable. This variability makes it challenging to ensure adequate pain relief during the procedure.
  • Masking Complications: Numbing creams can potentially mask early signs of complications, such as allergic reactions or improper piercing depth, making it harder for the piercer to address these issues promptly.
  • Safety and Liability: Reputable piercers prioritize safety and predictable outcomes. Numbing creams introduce too many variables that can compromise the piercing process and potentially lead to complications. Some piercing studios, like Koi Piercing Studio and Clinical Ear Piercing, even refuse to pierce numbed skin due to liability concerns.

Alternatives to Numbing Creams: Managing Piercing Pain Safely

If you’re concerned about piercing pain, discuss your options with your piercer. They can provide personalized advice and recommend alternative pain management techniques such as:

  • Deep Breathing Exercises: Deep, controlled breathing can help calm your nerves and reduce anxiety, making the piercing experience less stressful.
  • Distraction Techniques: Focusing on something else, like listening to music or chatting with your piercer, can help divert your attention from the procedure.
  • Over-the-Counter Pain Relievers: Taking an over-the-counter pain reliever, such as ibuprofen or acetaminophen, after the piercing (and as directed by a doctor) can help manage any lingering discomfort.

Post-Piercing Care: Prioritizing Healing

Once you’ve gotten your piercing, proper aftercare is essential for minimizing pain and preventing infection. Your piercer will provide detailed instructions, but generally, this involves cleaning the piercing with saline solution and avoiding touching or rotating the jewelry. While the temptation to use numbing cream for post-piercing soreness might be strong, it’s generally not recommended, as it can interfere with the healing process. Instead, opt for a cool chamomile tea compress to soothe the area and reduce swelling.

The Bottom Line: Informed Decisions for a Positive Piercing Experience

Numbing creams can play a role in reducing piercing pain, but their effectiveness and suitability vary depending on individual factors and the piercing location. Consulting with a reputable piercer is crucial for making an informed decision about whether numbing cream is right for you. They can assess your individual needs, discuss potential risks and benefits, and guide you toward the safest and most comfortable piercing experience possible. Remember, prioritizing safety and open communication with your piercer are key to a successful and enjoyable piercing journey.

Lola Sofia